Cheesecake Cutie - wedding cheesecakes

Add a unique touch with an unconventional wedding cake

There are few elements that effect the tone and style of your wedding like the wedding cake. And while some couples choose to go the traditional route of a classic cake enrobed in buttercream or fondant icing, others use their cake to showcase their unique style.

Going online to search for unique wedding cake ideas can be overwhelming with all of the choices available to brides and grooms. On Anna Maria Island, Jennifer Geils at The Cheesecake Cutie & Café specializes in making every couple’s unique wedding cake dreams come true with her magical recipe for cheesecake.

Jennifer’s one-of-a-kind, New York-style cheesecake recipe is handed down from her mother, Barbara Lanza who made her signature cheesecakes in New Jersey. At her Holmes Beach bakery, Jennifer makes 9-inch cheesecakes and her cheesecake cuties, individual cheesecakes the size of a large cupcake. Typically for weddings, Jennifer said couples choose a 9-inch cheesecake to cut and then provide a selection of different flavored cheesecake cuties for their guests.

Flavors range from B’s original cheesecake to key lime and candy flavored options. There also are seasonal favorites, like pumpkin pie and white chocolate peppermint, and boozy flavors including tiramisu and Kahlua to choose from. If someone on your guest list has a dietary restriction, don’t worry – there are gluten-free and keto options as well.

For couples with a particular flavor in mind, Jennifer says she’s willing to try anything as long as it tastes good and works with her mom’s cheesecake recipe. One of the more uncommon flavors she’s concocted over the years is a fruity pebbles cheesecake, which she said was fun challenge.

And she’s always working with the requests of friends, family and clients to come up with new flavors. Debuting in 2021 is an orangecicle cheesecake cutie, the latest confectionary feat to join her growing list of available flavors.

Flavors aren’t the only customization available for cheesecake wedding cakes. Jennifer and her talented staff can layer cheesecake colors and flavors to match vision of each couple.

One of the treats she’s working on especially with brides and grooms in mind is a layered cheesecake. The cake would mimic the look of a traditional layered wedding cake but be made of cheesecake instead of a flavored sponge cake.

The Cheesecake Cutie & Café also offers catering for bridal luncheons, rehearsal dinners and romantic getaways for couples taking a break from their wedding festivities. While trying out some of the available cheesecake flavors which vary daily, grab a few scuties, little bite-sized savory treats, or a custom created charcuterie plate.

To see everything that The Cheesecake Cutie & Café has to offer, visit the bakery online at

Add a unique touch with an unconventional wedding cake
Article Name
Add a unique touch with an unconventional wedding cake
Publisher Name
Anna Maria Island Weddings
Publisher Logo

Leave a Comment